Eclipse che vs theia

Eclipse Theia is an open source code editor that runs both as a desktop application and in the browser. The newly released version Theia 1. JAXenter: Eclipse Theia version 1.

eclipse che vs theia

Sven Efftinge: VS Code is an extremely good tool. In my opinion it offers just the right balance between a code editor and an IDE.

In addition, the strong focus on command line interfaces via terminal and the development of the Language Server Protocol finally allows to shift a lot of work to the communities. This is an extremely important design decision because it means that IDE-specific plugins do not have to be built for every framework and programming language. With Theia, we took all this over and solved three things that make VS code unusable for our purpose:.

Many people probably know that Microsoft itself has now developed Visual Studio Online, a version that runs in the browser. But back when we started the Theia project back, this was not an issue for the VS Code team, so there was no collaboration.

Unfortunately, VSO is not open source either, which means, for example, that it is not usable for us in Gitpod.

Building a Web-IDE based on Eclipse Theia for Smart Home - EclipseCon Europe 2018

VS Code is designed as a product for developers. Using it as a base for other organizations or products is not part of the idea. Therefore, the VS Code team does not provide extension and branding opportunities outside the extension mechanism. However, we wanted to create a basis that would allow many companies to build on the jointly developed platform in the true sense of open source. We wanted to develop a platform that — similar to the old Eclipse platform — could work in many different use cases.

When you develop a product that is heavily based on open source code, you want to depend as little as possible on the goodwill of individual companies, in this case Microsoft. That is why we are developing Theia under the umbrella of the Eclipse Foundation.

These three points are the elementary difference to VS Code and in this respect, Theia is not in competition with VS Code at all, because Microsoft has no interest in serving as a basis for products of other vendors. At least that was the case when we talked to the product manager at the time about a possible cooperation.

Of course, that is absolutely fine. For example, the Workbench Shell is much more flexible and generic than in VS code. Sven Efftinge: This refers to the lack of vendor neutrality. In addition, we constantly receive high-quality pull requests from many different organizations and individuals.

The Theia project is one of the most diverse and active projects under the umbrella of the Eclipse Foundation. Sven Efftinge: We continue to focus on providing a good quality platform to allow companies to develop their own tools based on Theia.

Stability and performance are especially important here. Furthermore, we will of course regularly implement the new features in the extension protocols of VS Code, which Theia natively supports. Theia already supports working with tablets especially iPadsbut we want to improve this significantly. Other topics we are currently discussing in the community include a multi-window mode that allows me to split Theia across multiple screens. Many have now asked for downloads for the desktop version of Theia 1.Eclipse Foundation hopes to give the popular Microsoft-developed Visual Studio Code source code editor some competition with the 1.

Eclipse Theia is a framework for building cloud and desktop integrated development environments IDEs. The platform enables developers to build a desktop application and transition it to run in the cloud without a rewrite.

Theia has the potential to repeat the original success of the Eclipse IDE platform almost 20 years ago, said Mike Milinkovich, executive director of the Ottawa-based Eclipse Foundation. However, "The Eclipse desktop IDE is going to be around and supported and very important for many, many years to come," he said. But the new generation of developers is looking for tools that use web technologies, as opposed to the desktop integration that came with the original Eclipse platform.

The 1. A version for the latter is expected by the fourth quarter of this year. With Theia, companies can build custom and white-labeled developer products, Milinkovich said. Many of these companies began adopting Theia before the 1. Eclipse Theia works as a native desktop application as well as in the context of a browser and a remote server, said Sven Efftinge, project lead for Theia and CEO of TypeFox.

It's this type of tight-cycle development where I could see Theia being an asset to developers. Theia uses many of the same open source software components that VS Code uses, including the terminal component and the Monaco code editor that powers VS Code, Efftinge said. Theia also natively supports VS Code extensions, including extensions for different programming languages, visual debugging and database connections. There is a marketplace for developers to get VS Code extensions, but Microsoft does not allow access to it from outside Visual Studio.

Theia 1. However, CodeMix users are explicitly forbidden from using Microsoft's VS Code marketplace to install extensions into CodeMix, even if those extensions were written by a non-Microsoft third party and provided under a compatible open source license. But Theia gets Genuitec around that restriction. Gitpod provides a continuous development environment, he added. We do the same thing just for dev environments.

You put the description of your development environment into your Git repository and anyone on your team can just click a button and get a fully working pre-built dev environment in a couple of seconds. Please check the box if you want to proceed.

As enterprises move in on RPA, they need developers who can juggle both the business and technical sides of automation. Here are Plenty of vendors have jumped on the API gateway trend, which can make it difficult to choose the right one for you.

We examine Before you build a microservices application, take a closer look at the components of the architecture and their capabilities. With GitHub Free, GitHub is making team software development free on the company's platform for hosting software development One piece of software might be well-suited for test automation while another won't.

Here are the factors to look for when you With a new AI engine for its contract lifecycle management CLM platform, Agiloft is giving developers assistance in building Cloud bursting might seem like a great way to handle traffic spikes, but it's rife with complications.

Still, it's not impossible Learn how AWS Lambda has been updated over the years to address shortcomings in its serverless computing platform, and how Let's take a look at on-premises vs. Organizations can reap benefits from IoT technology but only if it is properly secured. Learn the components of IoT networkIn this article, we compare Eclipse Che with Eclipse Theia and explain their relationship — their differences and their overlap.

In fact — spoiler alert — both technologies do combine well and together provide a very powerful stack for cloud-based tooling. So let us start right ahead with the most interesting question:. The Eclipse Che workspace server creates, manages and orchestrates developer environments that are running on a cloud container platform Kubernetes, Docker, OpenShift, etc. Che workspaces run in containers which provide all the dependencies that are needed to code, build, test, run and debug a project.

This component has similarities to Eclipse Theia, so the real question we need to ask is:. To keep the article concise, let us focus on the major differences:. Besides those major differences, both web IDEs have much in common, e.

Anyways, Eclipse Theia, for the web IDE part, is the clear winner and the more future-proof platform. Moreover, Red Hat, as the main driver behind Che has also engaged significant development efforts to improve and enrich Theia.

Eclipse launches Theia 1.0 as alternative to VS Code

Che 7 which has been released is the first version to officially support Eclipse Theia as a client IDE. That means you can create workspaces on the Che workspace server, which provide access via a ready-to-be-used version of the Eclipse Theia IDE. This flexibility, i. This splits workspaces into the core runtime and tools, while the second can be added to any runtime as sidecars. That allows to switch between different web-based IDEs. The default web-based IDE to be provided in Che 7 will be based on Eclipse Theia, but alternate web based editors are also available, such as as Eclipse Dirigible, Jupyter or any custom Theia:.

Eclipse Theia or in general a web-based IDE is only one of the pieces you need to create and operate a cloud-based tool. While Theia also comes with its own server part, you need some place to deploy it.

If you want to support one user with one workspace, you can just deploy your Theia backend somewhere and you are fine.

eclipse che vs theia

This is exactly were the Eclipse Che workspace server comes into play. It provides those missing features such as:. The Che workspace server is based on Docker and Kubernetes and therefore even scales well.

Eclipse Theia vs. VS Code: “Theia is one of the most diverse & active projects”

Finally, it can be deployed on-premises or remotely, so it is even ready to be used in larger enterprises. To conclude on the original comparison, Eclipse Che vs.We focus on the scenario of using these technologies as a basis for custom extensions as well as for the implementation of a domain-specific tool. If you just look for a slim and modern code editor, most developers would at the moment just download VS Code.

However, if are thinking about developing a custom tool, an IDE extension or even a full stack service offering for developers, the choice becomes much less trivial. Should you base your solution on Eclipse Theia, should you provide a VS Code extension, or eventually even both? At EclipseSource, we support various customers with writing custom VS Code extensions, creating extensions for Eclipse Theia, and with developing full, white-labeled products.

eclipse che vs theia

As we typically also provide advice beforehand, which technology to choose for a specific project, we want to share some generic guidelines on this question in this article. As often is the case, when it comes to technology decisions, a good decision requires a detailed look at the requirements of your project as well as a proper evaluation of the available choices compared to your goals.

According to some recent surveysit might be the most popular code editor at the moment. The project was announced by Microsoft in The project was incepted in more details here and has been an Eclipse open source project since Theia reuses quite a few technologies and concepts from VS Code, but it supported online deployment as well as a desktop deployment via electron right from its beginning.

Eclipse Theia is available under the Eclipse Public License EPL and its development is supported by a variety of contributing companies see here. Before we dive into a technical comparison or look at the ecosystem, let us outline some quite conceptual differences between Eclipse Theia and VS Code. VS Code is a product, that you as a developer can download and use out-of-the-box. If you miss any features, you can install VS Code extensions from the extensive ecosystem, e.

Eclipse Theia, in contrast, is a framework to build IDEs and tools on. This does not imply that you cannot use Theia out-of-the-box. As outlined in this article on how to launch Theiathere are even multiple ways to get to a running Theia IDE within seconds. However, if you want to keep the comparison very simple: VS Code is an off-the-shelf product, which users can download and extend and it is already very commonly used.

Eclipse Theia is a framework allowing the creation of completely custom and white-labeled products. While the direction of this statement is true, it does not cover all facts. In fact, Eclipse Theia also allows the user to install plugins.In this article series we provide an overview on how to get started with Eclipse Theia and Che. In case you are wondering what Eclipse Theia is, please see here for an introduction to Theia and here for the relationship between Theia and Che.

Let us dive right into the first question in the following section. Theia provides two mechanisms to add new features to it: extensions and plugins see here for the difference and more details on Eclipse Theia extensions and plugins. The Theia plugin API does miss some features compared to VS code, but the coverage is already pretty good and progressing well.

As a consequence you can install and use many VS Code plugins in Theia without any modification! This leads us to the next topic. To enable plugins in general and VS Code plugins in particular, you first need to add two extensions to your Eclipse Theia instance, which are listed below please see this article for more details on how to add extensions to Theia.

After you have activated these extensions, you can use the command bar in Theia to install plugins. This ID can be found in the marketplace. The following command would install the ESLint extension into Theia although you should not do this, see below :.

However, this way of installing an extension from the VS Code marketplace is currently forbidden by its terms of use, which only allow to install content from the marketplace into VS Code. As a work around, you can get the respective VS Code extensions from its original source and install it from a custom location, i.

If you run Theia within Che, you can actually use the same mechanism as described above. It allows you to select from a precompiled list of plugins from a Che specific plugin registry. Further it allows to add custom registries, e. However VS Code extension often requires underlying tools to be available. Vanilla Theia will not do that for you.

If you use Theia within Eclipse Che, you can alternatively use the Eclipse Che plugin mechanism see here for more details on Eclipse Che-Theia plugins. As Che plugins can also contain runtime components, they typically bundle everything you need in order to use a certain tool into a single Che plugin.

The disadvantage is that you can only use what is explicitly provided as a Theia-Che plugin and not any plugin from any marketplace or registry.

However, the list of Theia-Che plugins in continuously growing and the team welcomes contributions too. Additionally, you can define your own plugin registry and add any available VS Code extension with its runtime dependencies.

It allows users of Theia to access the comprehensive ecosystem around VS Code. The main challenge is to test as many VS Code extensions with Theia as possible. This is where you can help the team and provide feedback. So if you are interested in using a VS Code extension in Theia, please follow this guide on how to test them and how to create feedback.

If you need support in making your favorite VS Code extension work in Eclipse Theia, or you want to create your own VS Code extension which is compatible with Theia, want to provide a custom product based on Eclipse Theia or Che, need general support and advice on Eclipse Theiathen have a look at our service offering for web-based tools or tools in general and please get in contact with us! Finally, if you are interested in future parts of this series, e.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.What is Eclipse Che? Eclipse Che is an open source developer workspace server and cloud IDE. It's as powerful as it sounds. What is Theia? Eclipse Che and Theia are both open source tools.

Cloud IDE shoot-out: AWS Cloud9 vs. Eclipse Che vs. Eclipse Theia

It seems that Eclipse Che with 5. Eclipse Che 43 Stacks. Theia 17 Stacks. Need advice about which tool to choose? Ask the StackShare community! Eclipse Che. Visit Eclipse Che. Eclipse Che vs Theia: What are the differences? Eclipse Che makes Kubernetes development accessible for developer teams, providing one-click developer workspaces and eliminating local environment configuration for your entire team.

Why do developers choose Eclipse Che? Why do developers choose Theia? Be the first to leave a pro. Sign up to add, upvote and see more pros Make informed product decisions. What are the cons of using Eclipse Che? What are the cons of using Theia? Be the first to leave a con. What companies use Eclipse Che?

eclipse che vs theia

What companies use Theia? Sign up to get full access to all the companies Make informed product decisions. What tools integrate with Eclipse Che? What tools integrate with Theia? Amazon EC2. Google Compute Engine.JAXenter: Eclipse Theia version 1. Sven Efftinge: VS Code is an extremely good tool. In my opinion it offers just the right balance between a code editor and an IDE. In addition, the strong focus on command line interfaces via terminal and the development of the Language Server Protocol finally allows to shift a lot of work to the communities.

This is an extremely important design decision because it means that IDE-specific plugins do not have to be built for every framework and programming language. With Theia, we took all this over and solved three things that make VS code unusable for our purpose:. Many people probably know that Microsoft itself has now developed Visual Studio Online, a version that runs in the browser. But back when we started the Theia project back, this was not an issue for the VS Code team, so there was no collaboration.

Unfortunately, VSO is not open source either, which means, for example, that it is not usable for us in Gitpod. VS Code is designed as a product for developers. Using it as a base for other organizations or products is not part of the idea. Therefore, the VS Code team does not provide extension and branding opportunities outside the extension mechanism.

However, we wanted to create a basis that would allow many companies to build on the jointly developed platform in the true sense of open source. We wanted to develop a platform that — similar to the old Eclipse platform — could work in many different use cases. When you develop a product that is heavily based on open source code, you want to depend as little as possible on the goodwill of individual companies, in this case Microsoft.

That is why we are developing Theia under the umbrella of the Eclipse Foundation. These three points are the elementary difference to VS Code and in this respect, Theia is not in competition with VS Code at all, because Microsoft has no interest in serving as a basis for products of other vendors. At least that was the case when we talked to the product manager at the time about a possible cooperation.

Of course, that is absolutely fine. For example, the Workbench Shell is much more flexible and generic than in VS code. Sven Efftinge: This refers to the lack of vendor neutrality.

In addition, we constantly receive high-quality pull requests from many different organizations and individuals. The Theia project is one of the most diverse and active projects under the umbrella of the Eclipse Foundation. Sven Efftinge: We continue to focus on providing a good quality platform to allow companies to develop their own tools based on Theia.

Stability and performance are especially important here. Furthermore, we will of course regularly implement the new features in the extension protocols of VS Code, which Theia natively supports. Theia already supports working with tablets especially iPadsbut we want to improve this significantly.

Other topics we are currently discussing in the community include a multi-window mode that allows me to split Theia across multiple screens. Many have now asked for downloads for the desktop version of Theia 1. The Theia project is led by Marc Dumais Ericsson and me.


thoughts on “Eclipse che vs theia

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *